Nobody Told Me Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The menu was an inspired take on traditional bar food."
• "Great burger, amaaaazing truffle queso."
• "The french toast sticks were absolutely delicious, soft and pillowy."
• "The spicy chicken sandwich was to die for."
• "Everything our group ordered was good, if not great."
• "The food was amazing, especially the cheeseburger."
• "The spicy chicken sandwich with fries had great flavor."

Cons:

• "Eggplant dip was salty. Couldn’t taste the eggplant."
• "The dates has almonds in the middle. Not great. Parm would have been much better."
• "The Mac and cheese was just a tad too salty for me."
• "The food isn't expensive either to balance the pricey drinks out."
• "Not to mention the food was cold and bland."
• "First, I almost swallowed a rubber band that was into my salad!"
• "Today was really disappointing and I don’t think they will stay open for too long."

Service

Pros:

• "The bartenders are attentive & kind."
• "The staff is friendly and efficient."
• "Katie (the bartender) provided top class service (was really friendly and accommodating to our group)."
• "Staff is friendly, drinks are tasty, and the food is delicious."
• "Staff were friendly and quick to help with ordering."
• "The bar manager, Matt, somehow placed drinks in our hands within minutes of ordering."
• "The staff here is attentive, friendly, and has good recommendations."

Cons:

• "The only place you can order food is at the bar from the bartender, who is of course busy making drinks for everyone else."
• "Took over an hour when it says 20-30 mins then half my food was missing and there is no # to call them in google."
• "Fun vibe, but the middle aged white male bartender has terrible energy and was rude to several people in our party when we were ordering drinks."
• "Stopped by to place an order for food, but apparently the staff here is too busy flirting to give any attention to would be customers."
• "The service was terrible; the bartender would come to our table and say our drink was ready but never brought it."
• "Prepare to wait a LONG time for service until the staff is done taking shots with customers or drinking their own cocktails behind the bar."
• "The servers/bus boys are way too aggressive. They don't even let you take the final sip before they take it."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Comforting atmosphere, brunch all day long any day."
• "Best cocktail bar in the neighborhood by a good stretch."
• "The music is super vibey."
• "It's a cool vibe, music in the background, but not so loud that guests can't hold conversations."
• "Really nice place with dim lighting and music to get you dancing."
• "This is the most fun spot to chill at."
• "Great wallpapers and lighting in bright airy space with comfortable bar booths."

Cons:

• "Cocktails are pretty good. If you don't like loud restaurants and bars, I would avoid this place."
• "Good vibes but music too loud."
• "Only caveat: the music can be too loud to have a normal conversation."
• "Also, it's winter, no reason to have it be FREEZING cold in there."
• "I had to lower my rating due to the volume of music being unpleasantly loud."
• "Bad customer service to brown people (women)."
• "None more than last night, at 5.30pm on a Saturday trying to order a glass of red wine, only to be told by the bartender they were not only out of the Malbec I ordered, but had run out of ALL red wine."

Drinks

Pros:

• "Drinks are really good and bartenders are cool however they get slammed since there is one maybe two people working making all the drinks."
• "I ordered the Call to Arms drink and it is honestly one of the best gin drinks I've ever had!"
• "The drinks were phenomenal (mezcal Negroni; copy of a copy; search and destroy) and the food was delectable."
• "The lemonades and juice were perfect, great taste, very fresh."
• "Cocktails are 🔥."
• "Pricey, but well-made and innovative cocktails (though some you're paying for ice more than the alcohol /a flavor)."
• "Nobody Told Me has some phenomenal cocktails."

Cons:

• "The drink was decent but I would try a different one when I come back."
• "Drinks are creative but does not mean they taste good."
• "In no world should a low-ball glass of DIET COKE FROM THE BAR SPOUT be 5 bucks (before tip!) That's ridiculous."
• "Assemble the Empire was on the sweet side, but good for people that would enjoy something berry forward."
• "this is by far the worst restaurant i have ever been in NYC. The staff is rude, the drinks are basically a 17$ cup of ice and the service is a disaster."
• "'Happy Hour' menu items are roughly $2 less than the non-happy hour menu, which is pointless in my opinion."
• "None more than last night, at 5.30pm on a Saturday trying to order a glass of red wine, only to be told by the bartender they were not only out of the Malbec I ordered, but had run out of ALL red wine."