Mezcali Reviews Summary

Category: Mexican restaurant New York

Address: 83 Maiden Ln, New York, NY 10038, USA

Phone: +19174095881

Rating: 4.4
based on 127 reviews.

Drinks

Pros:

  • "The drinks were amazing and had a kick to them."
  • "Margaritas had a kick and veggie quesadillas were delicious!"
  • "Great drinks!!! We had multiple mezcalitas and some of their signature cocktails and they were all unique and delicious."
  • "Cocktails are one of the best!!"
  • "really good margaritas and mezcal cocktails."
  • "Some of the best margaritas I've ever tasted."
  • "The spicy margaritas were amazing."

Cons:

  • "Cocktail was a tad stronger than I’m used to but I don’t mind."
  • "Disappointed that when we received them they were room temperature."
  • "The drinks were very watered down."
  • "The 5-6 margaritas we wanted to drink unfortunately (/luckily?) never happened after all. :("
  • "Only had a variety of their cocktails and candidly, they were not discernable from one another."
  • "The drinks were okay. They were a bit pricey and could have been a little bit stronger."
  • "It took quite a while to get our drinks when we were the only people here."

Service

Pros:

  • "Service was great and the food was delicious."
  • "Amazing service and drinks."
  • "Server was super nice."
  • "The staff was very friendly and welcoming (excellent service πŸ‘πŸ»)."
  • "The two servers were attentive and friendly."
  • "They are very friendly and super attentive."
  • "Great service, great staff."

Cons:

  • "It was difficult to get the servers attention and they had forgot to provide the bill to us even after a couple of requests."
  • "Sadly the service wasn't satisfying we had to order direct at bar since the waiter lost our drinks at least once."
  • "Service was disappointing even though the drinks were good."
  • "The issue was service being very careless and unprofessional."
  • "Service on a Friday night was horrible."
  • "During our meal our waitress NEVER came back once after taking our order."
  • "The service sucks."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The vibe was calm, inviting and the music neo soul/hip hop."
  • "Love the open windows at the front - such a unique experience."
  • "The atmosphere is fantastic."
  • "The place is beautiful! Warm with neutral tones and unlike any other TexMex restaurant I’ve ever seen."
  • "This place has the best ambiance for get-togethers and dinner with loved ones."
  • "The atmosphere was so beautiful and romantic."
  • "The atmosphere was amazing, the staff was super friendly and helpful and the food was well flavored."

Cons:

  • "It's expensive and the music is extremely loud."
  • "Incredibly loud after work. Suggest avoiding if you're trying to have a conversation."
  • "It gets way too loud inside."
  • "We had to shout ourselves in the super loud background music."
  • "Good looking space with loud music."
  • "The music definitely enhanced the vibes but not sure if the volume added to the extra loud talking battles at each group/table."
  • "can be a bit loud due to the open space concept."

Food

Pros:

  • "Despite the cost, the taste is worth savoring."
  • "Everything was super good. The dumplings could have a been a little warmer.. but we did order a lot."
  • "Nachos, elote, sea bass dish were the tastiest ones we had."
  • "The food is on point."
  • "Started with chips and salsa, very delicious and crispy w/ 3 different sauces (all 3 were great)."
  • "The food was incredible! And the blueberry cobbler was unmatched."
  • "All of the food was delicious! Really impressed for it being their second day open."

Cons:

  • "The elote was not elote at all."
  • "This might be the worst Mexican food I ever had."
  • "I spent over $30 buck on one order of tacos and grilled peppers but was still hungry."
  • "The accompanying veggies were much too salty."
  • "The food and service is spotty."
  • "The food was only meh."
  • "The food was just okay."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.