Red Line Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner

Address: 588 US-9, Fishkill, NY 12524, USA

Phone: +18457658401

Rating: 4.4
based on 278 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was delicious. My burger was super juicy."
  • "I had the Street Corn and Black Bean Quesadilla - highly recommend!"
  • "The steak was great charred perfectly with a nice seasoning as were the shrimp."
  • "The food is fabulous, and the large portions that they give made this diner a had to return the same day experience for me."
  • "Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious."
  • "The chicken was moist and delicious on both sandwiches, both very good."
  • "Food was as ordered, fast, hot and tasty."

Cons:

  • "The cheese on the French onion soup was burnt on the top and barely melted on the bottom."
  • "The food was very bland. No flavor."
  • "Food was bland."
  • "The only thing I disagree with is if I get like a club sandwich or a BLT and I ask to take the tomatoes off and add onions, then charge me for the onions."
  • "Virtually no flavor. Looked great but lacked seasoning."
  • "The burgers I ordered were nothing short of a disappointment, as they were incredibly unseasoned and lacked any flavor whatsoever."
  • "The fried chicken was sweet in a unpleasant way."

Service

Pros:

  • "Service was great, vibes were great, for was great."
  • "All the servers who attended to my needs were friendly & attentive."
  • "The service is extremely friendly, fun and attentive."
  • "Our server was terrific and the food was exceptional!"
  • "The service is amazing! The food is great!"
  • "The waitress was prompt and knowledgeable."
  • "Service is always very good."

Cons:

  • "The guy who we can only assume was the manager... brought us to a table with only 1 set of silverware that was still dirty."
  • "Service is way below average."
  • "Waitress was forgetful, never offered refills on drinks and never gave us silverware."
  • "Our waitress was running around like crazy, so you can tell she was extremely overwhelmed."
  • "Because of her and her alone. I will never go back."
  • "The service was so slow and inattentive."
  • "Overpriced! The man seating us who I think might have also been the owner was rude and abrupt."

Atmosphere & Decor

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere feels expansive and roomy."
  • "I look for cleanliness and this place was spotless."
  • "The decor is retro modern with a 50's diner feeling but without the long narrow layout of an actual 50's diner."
  • "Beautiful old school feel diner with great food at amazing prices."
  • "The interior is a mix of modern and retro of diners past styles."
  • "Very cool retro style atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere, with its diner charm, adds a nostalgic touch to the dining experience."

Cons:

  • "It's kinda of a turn off with everything thrown on top like trash."
  • "The decor is old school so if you’re looking for fancy this isn’t it."
  • "It also happens to be just a bit more expensive than an average diner."
  • "The atmosphere was very festive with holiday decor."
  • "Atmosphere looks great. Beautiful lights and brilliant red lights and red and chrome architectural design."
  • "Expect to be greeted with every seasonal display inside the Dinner."
  • "I like the overall vintage atmosphere of the dinner."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.