Tabernacle Steakhouse Reviews Summary

Category: Kosher restaurant New York

Address: 315 W 36th St., New York, NY 10018, USA

Phone: +12129337001

Rating: 4.6
based on 242 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our waiter was so professional and helpful."
  • "The staff (especially Sharif) is attentive, personable, and treats you like you are the only customer in the restaurant."
  • "The service was first class and attentive."
  • "Staff is outstanding, food is beyond delicious, every dish is made to perfection."
  • "Servers were attentive and helpful."
  • "The service was beyond five star!"
  • "The staff was very professional and knowledgeable of the menu."

Cons:

  • "I wish the waiter wouldn't have asked me every 2/3 minutes how I'm enjoying and the food were better."
  • "The wait staff was a bit pushy when it came to ordering our meals."
  • "The waiting was unacceptable, over 20 minutes for drinks, entrees that never came."
  • "Took our waiter forever to come get our orders."
  • "The wait staff was difficult concerning COVID."
  • "The waitstaff was very friendly but the service was very slow."
  • "Service and waiting for any small detail like a coke or a French fries... is minimum 20 minutes."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The decor and ambiance is 5 stars."
  • "The ambiance is second to none and it was a truly joyful experience."
  • "The vibe was classy yet relaxing."
  • "The ambiance of the restaurant is immaculate and their attention to detail shines through."
  • "The ambiance and decor here are amazing and add to the whole experience."
  • "Ambiance was amazing."
  • "The ambiance is wonderfully done with lot of references to the Tabernacle winery."

Cons:

  • "Restaurant atmosphere is tired and probably due for some renovations and updates."
  • "Nice ambiance but not particularly trendy looking inside."
  • "The attitude from those who were not directly waiting on us was condescending and dismissive."
  • "The area is extremely dangerous and scary."
  • "Area is terrible."
  • "The completely empty restaurant at 6pm should have been our sign to try going somewhere else."
  • "When you pay high-end prices, you'd expect high-end dishes. These dishes look like a kid put them together. No class. No decor no garnish."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Boneless Ribeye - Perfectly spiced and cooked to a nice pink medium rare."
  • "The steak dishes were so juicy and done just right."
  • "The food at Tabernacle is delicious, each dish carefully curated to tantalize your taste buds and leaving you desiring for more."
  • "The food was out of this world!!!"
  • "The juicy and succulent steak was the perfect complement to the appetizers."
  • "The food was wonderful."
  • "Food was absolutely amazing! I had the best sushi roll of my life called the Tabernacle."

Cons:

  • "Extremely overpriced for mediocre food."
  • "The roasted chicken had a weird smell and flavor."
  • "The steak came out and looked like it was cooked well, but was completely flavorless."
  • "The food was not good at all the food we got was meatball sliders which was supposed to have 'bone marrow' BS TASTE LIKE FROZEN MEATBALLS disgusting."
  • "The rib steak was not seasoned properly."
  • "Food is a disaster."
  • "The soup was terrible. The risotto looked like someone threw up in a bowl and tasted the same way."

Value

Pros:

  • "The Maryland crabcakes are homemade and quite large; well worth the price."
  • "A bit pricey but so worth it!"
  • "For a kosher restaurant the prices are really reasonable."
  • "Prices were fair for the amount of food you receive."
  • "It’s money well spent."
  • "Although the menu is certainly on the pricey side, this is justified by the high-end and high-quality dining experience we received."
  • "Absolutely the best kosher restaurant in America. Maybe the world."

Cons:

  • "Our bill was over $2,000."
  • "You will walk out with a minimum between $700-1500 easy."
  • "The food was pretty decent but for the price, it was not worth it."
  • "No burger should ever be $52 unless there's gold in it."
  • "The example of the fries is tasteless despite their steep price ($16)."
  • "The quality of the food didn't quite live up to the cost."
  • "This space is extremely expensive and not worth a dollar."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.