Newberry's Yard of Ale Reviews Summary

Category: Bar

Address: 622 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA

Phone: +15705170130

Rating: 4.1
based on 172 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Matthew, our server, was attentive and pleasant."
  • "Ashley was an excellent hostess who was perfect with her timing and grace."
  • "Great service the bartender Ian was very kind and accommodating."
  • "Wonderful service. We will definitely be back."
  • "The bartender was super friendly."
  • "Staff friendly and courteous."
  • "The staff was super friendly and very quick service."

Cons:

  • "The waitress was distracted and the restaurant wasn't even busy."
  • "Manager chastised wait staff in front of us for standing around and talking instead of checking on tables."
  • "Only issue we had was the server really seemed flustered."
  • "Not to mention our waitress was horrible!"
  • "When we spoke with the manager, she was quite rude."
  • "The service has always been pretty poor."
  • "Service terrible (sky was slow, and had a bad attitude and seemed far more interested at sitting at the bar and not working)."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "We really enjoyed the atmosphere of the pub."
  • "The vibe is positive and the music selection also appropriate for the atmosphere."
  • "Very charming atmosphere."
  • "Cool atmosphere too."
  • "We stopped in for lunch and was greeted with a great atmosphere!"
  • "Perfect spot for good food, especially outside! Bring the kids, bring the puppies!"
  • "Great atmosphere."

Cons:

  • "We sat in the back and it smelled like someone just went number 2."
  • "It's sad because it's a nice looking place."
  • "Not a great place to sit outside."
  • "The atmosphere was very nice."
  • "The place looks really nice, but I was less than impressed."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food is always fresh and delicious."
  • "The pizza is excellent."
  • "However whatever cheese they used was phenomenal."
  • "The food was really GOOD!"
  • "Stellar corned beef & cabbage! Beef was as tender as filet mignon, cut thick, ultra-delicious."
  • "The food was fresh and delicious."
  • "The food was excellent."

Cons:

  • "They are charging 10 times what their food is worth."
  • "The kitchen was also out of a lot of food! Not ideal when you are bringing new clientele into the restaurant."
  • "The food wasn't great. It tasted fresh but wasn't well executed."
  • "Food was just ok."
  • "It was bland and dry and tasted like salt-less progresso soup."
  • "The cesar wrap. It was very dry."
  • "Oh and don't order the 8-inch pizza what a waste of money it's all dough the kitchen needs help badly."

Price

Pros:

  • "We couldn't believe when our bill was less than 50 dollars."

Cons:

  • "This might be the state of the world, this might be taking advantage of being in the Poconos... but unfortunately I can't justify $9 a beer."
  • "They are charging 10 times what their food is worth."
  • "On top of this they charged me for requesting condiments for my burger?"
  • "Beer menu is extensive, but also pricey."
  • "Beer selection was pretty good but way overpriced."
  • "For the past 12 years coming here this had always been 5 stars no question.... but one shared lunch and a couple beers for $84 for my wife and I.... unreal."
  • "Leading to a $70 bill for 2 wraps, fries, and 2 beers for lunch. Ridiculous in my opinion."

Management

Pros:

  • "The proprietor was there during our visit and made sure we were getting good service."
  • "The owner greeted us before we left and we enjoyed hearing about the pup's three year history."
  • "Owner is often in - and doesn't want you to get Parking Tickets!"

Cons:

  • "Manager chastised wait staff in front of us for standing around and talking instead of checking on tables."
  • "When we spoke with the manager, she was quite rude."
  • "Terrible ownership and Management of this restaurant."
  • "Poorly run restaurant, does not seem to have a Manager or head wait staff overseeing the entire restaurant."
  • "This place needs new ownership."
  • "Anyways, when bringing up these complaints with the manager, she never once apologized for our dissatisfied service and yelled at me as I left."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.