Category: Italian restaurant Atlantic City, New Jersey
Address: 2825 Atlantic Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA
Phone: +16093446913
Rating: 4.6
based on 207 reviews.
Value
Pros:
"This place is pricy but worth it for the experience."
"Not the cheapest place but you are in A.C., and its well worth the price."
"expensive BUT soooo worth it!!"
"It's worth the money."
"The food quality was amazing and their prices for what you get quality wise is worth every penny."
"The experience and meal was worth every penny."
"The cost of dinner was worth it. We will be back."
Cons:
"twice we couldn't get an item on the menu"
"It felt as though the prices were high for the sake of exclusivity, not because of an added value or experience."
"Been to better places for less money"
"Overall for $207 with 20% tip for table side mozzarella with peppers, 4 sodas (2 of which were refills), 2 entrees, and 1 piece of blueberry cheesecake I would say not worth it."
"Paying $30. for what was no more than 1-2 oz. of pasta is over the top."
"Very disappointing and pricey(eg.$32 for Chicken Parmigiana)."
"The food was just OK and they charged us $58 for a $7 bottle of wine!!!"
Service
Pros:
"service is on point"
"Mathew was our waiter and was delightful!"
"The wait staff were excellent, polite, and on top of everything. Perfect service."
"Service was excellent and the restaurant is beautiful."
"Service was great, owner came over to check on us, waiters were on point, food served hot."
"An absolute gem. Service was exceptional."
"The service is exceptional are very happy to help"
Cons:
"The server was just ok"
"After calling over 200 times and scheduling weeks in advance, you'd think our experience would have been better."
"We didn’t order any alcohol and it seemed because of that the service wasn’t as attentive as other tables."
"Cafe 2825 was child friendly and this was not the case when we arrived"
"Food was good and the service was attentive albeit rather impersonal."
"The service was indifferent at best."
"Food was ok, but the service was horrible."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"atmosphere is warm and inviting"
"The atmosphere was just what you expect from such a restaurant and the owner was so nice."
"Beautiful atmosphere"
"The atmosphere excellent!"
"The atmosphere was very romantic."
"Loved the atmosphere and the service was great."
"The atmosphere, tableside service experience, and notorious exclusivity of this dining establishment are second to none."
Cons:
"The restaurant is dimly lit and has an unpleasant odor."
"The outdoor seating area is a bit loud. If you're looking for a quiet dinner, inside would be better."
"Extremely loud and it was impossible to enjoy a dinner conversation."
"Paper over the table clothes at a place with minimum $200 spend is just lazy to me."
"It’s a small dark restaurant, quite claustrophobic."
"It was LOUD to the point we had to raise our voices right across the 2 person table to hear each other."
"The only downside might be the noise level inside—it can get quite loud, making it challenging to converse."
Food Quality
Pros:
"Food is literally OMG level."
"The pork chop was unbelievably moist. The flavor is like no pork chop I ever had!"
"The details make the difference. Food is awesome."
"food is melt in your mouth delicious"
"The food was unbelievable"
"This is some of the finest Italian food you’ll ever eat."
"The food is the best I have tasted"
Cons:
"The zucchini flowers were soggy and the cheese wasn’t even warm."
"The carbonara dish I ordered was excessively oily."
"The food is good but not as impressive I’ve heard."
"The stuffed veal i would NOT recommend AS IT WAS JUST BLAH...NOTHING SPECIAL."
"The veal parm was horrific. Most likely frozen. It was so watery."
"Completely flavorless!!"
"The veal was okay, although overcooked and rubbery."
Reservation Process
Pros:
"Worth the calls for a res- they don't book out past a week so make sure you call at the right time."
"They take reservations by phone a maximum of two weeks in advance."
"Make reservations exactly 14 days in advanced."
"Reserve a table or call to see if seating is available at the bar."
"Great food, definitely make a reservation."
"Difficult reservations, but so worth it"
"Not easy to get in, they only accept reservations 2 weeks in advance."
Cons:
"After calling over 200 times and scheduling weeks in advance, you'd think our experience would have been better."
"I've hears nothing but great things about this place but I'm assuring I'll never find out..trying to get in touch with this place is an exercise in futility."
"Called 3 times within a 6 week period to make a reservation weeks in advance. No one ever picked up."
"I called a month in advance... but she told me to call back that they don't take reservations that early"
"Anyone who chooses to charge $50 PER head for an emergency cancellation is off the list."
"they will not return your message if there is no availability"
"Wish restaurants with web sites would keep them up to date. This place is closed till mid January."