Fish Market Reviews Summary

Category: Sports bar New York

Address: 111 South St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Phone: +19173638101

Rating: 4.5
based on 151 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The fried rice was amazing. I liked it a lot more than I expected to."
  • "So good, especially the drunken fish soup and fisherman's stew."
  • "Their food is delicious! We ordered bok choy, chicken wings, chicken curry, and fried rice and they were all great!"
  • "The laksa and fried rice were delish!"
  • "Excellent fish soup. Excellent curry chicken."
  • "The crispy fried rice, now THIS is what you MUST get!"
  • "The crunchy fried rice is so delicious."

Cons:

  • "It’s simply overpriced for what they serve."
  • "They have prawns for 25$(5$ for 1 prawn. Insane price for such place."
  • "We paid $19 for 5 shrimps and almost no fries."
  • "The seafood was only decent, but very overpriced for what it was."
  • "Worst restaurant, I was eating there fried rice there was a piece of plastic in it!!"
  • "Everything was deep fried to the point of being dry and tasteless."
  • "The rice was clumpy and the chicken was just so-so."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff are incredible, the food is amazing and the free Jameson shots make me happy."
  • "The food was great and the service was even better!"
  • "Staff goes above and beyond to make you feel like part of the family."
  • "The bartender was very friendly and quickly took care of us as soon as they opened."
  • "The staff and owners are friendly."
  • "The service was friendly."
  • "Wait staff was extremely personable."

Cons:

  • "The owner of the bar had his staff beat me up and throw me on the street 5 minutes after i walked in."
  • "Being rude to customers & having 0 communication between their staffs."
  • "The waitress was very rude and clearly did not want to serve two African American women."
  • "The service is slow... The owner is crazy or always drunk... Not very clean...I do not recommend..."
  • "Fat man behind the bar is on a power trip."
  • "Upon trying to place my order and open my own tab I was not only personally ridiculed by the overweight bartender, but he announced to my table that I had tried to open a new tab and that new tabs would not be accepted."
  • "Head staff were incredibly rude."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The vibe here is always friendly and good timey."
  • "Phenomenal local dive, serving fantastic seafood and Asian fare in a super casual environment."
  • "I love the variety of the menu and the fun atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere is so chill. No frills."
  • "It's comfortable and filled with positive, unpretentious energy!"
  • "Ambience is appealing."
  • "Feels like a neighborhood bar and just the right kind of dive-y."

Cons:

  • "The chubby Asian guy behind the bar is an angry nasty pos."
  • "However, it is insanely loud and for some people this is probably a good thing ... but for anyone trying to talk or really even hear themselves think this may not be the place for you."
  • "This place was very loud. The owners should really do something about the acoustics."
  • "The place doesn’t have capacity to support big groups of people, doesn’t have any organization, the owner doesn’t know how to deal with people and he is violent."
  • "The door glass is cracked and the doorknob is missing, makes it hard to notice or even enter from the outside."
  • "The place is a bit divey. It's got this damp basement feel to it, and most of the tables/seats don't match."
  • "Place is little bit creepy. Broken glass door, broken toilet door with paper plate covering the hole in the door."

Value

Pros:

  • "The prices were rather affordable for the amount of food you received."
  • "And at $12 for three tacos and fries, that's a great deal!"
  • "Great little spot in fidi! The prices are great."
  • "Best not only in the city, but anywhere, when it comes to staff, atmosphere, food, and prices."
  • "Great prices, friendliest owners around that deserve all the success."
  • "They serve up so much complimentary Jameson that you'll be doing just fine."
  • "Cheap beer and lobster in lower Manhattan? Free shots of whiskey?"

Cons:

  • "It’s simply overpriced for what they serve."
  • "They have prawns for 25$(5$ for 1 prawn. Insane price for such place."
  • "We paid $19 for 5 shrimps and almost no fries."
  • "The seafood was only decent, but very overpriced for what it was."
  • "Food seems alright until you notice that they are over charging."
  • "Too pricey for what you get."
  • "You’ll feel bad pay full price and leave."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.