"The young gentleman with an accent was extremely polite, hospitable and helpful."
"All staff were friendly and attentive."
"The best service we have had on our trip to NY. Servers and management came to our table frequently to make sure we were taken care of."
"The service staff is kind and always full of smiles no matter what time I stop by for a bite."
"The bartenders are fun, attentive and knowledgeable."
"Our server was knowledgeable, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed to enjoy our meal."
"The staff was super friendly, food delicious and drinks plentiful."
Cons:
"Bathrooms could've been cleaner."
"Included gratuity for a questionable service is not something you want to experience."
"A VERY HOMOPHOBIC EXPERIENCE. I feel very offended and worried."
"The waitress was not only inattentive she was not very helpful."
"With a group, when asked if we could split our bill, our server was apprehensive and replied with 'oh Jesus, Bro'."
"The place is definitely not service oriented."
"The wait times were beyond outrageous & my waitress was incredibly rude."
Food Quality
Pros:
"Menu was very good, lots of choices."
"The Pils was one of the best I ever had in the USA."
"This bar is everything an irish bar should be, good whiskey, great bar food, and amazing staff!!!"
"Fish and chips were on point. Delicious!"
"Both the Pepperoni Pizza and later the Gaelic Burger were delicious!"
"Food was hot and tasty."
"The ribs were outstanding. They were perfectly cooked and the sauce was terrific."
Cons:
"Food was not that great, expected more with the reviews. My cheeseburger had no taste."
"The chicken was cubes of tough & rubbery meat, that I imagine came from a can."
"Just don't get the 'giant pretzel' it's not a pretzel. It's basically a huge amount of pizza dough that doesn't even taste that good."
"The supposedly medium well burgers were extremely dry they had been cooked so long."
"Food was disgusting. I ordered their weekly flatbread with spinach and artichokes and mozzarella to get spinach artichoke dip on large pitas chips with copious slices of mozzarella on top."
"The fish and chips was pre-portioned pre-breaded overcooked sub-gortens type frozen seafood."
"The food was forgettable (or maybe unforgettable is a better description)."
Atmosphere and Location
Pros:
"This is THE PLACE TO BE for that authentic sports bar/pub experience."
"The atmosphere is great and the staff are friendly and attentive."
"Standard Irish pub done well."
"It’s a comfortable, clean pub with a great menu that’s worth your time, no matter what your name is."
"Great atmosphere and friendly accommodating staff."
"This place is really a hidden gem with authentic Irish pub vibes."
"Wonderful, casual, fun atmosphere with a wide variety of drinks & food at great prices in a convenient location right by Rockefeller Center!"
Cons:
"It's loud and certainly not like any Irish bar I've been to stateside or otherwise."
"We called and spoke to the manager who never apologized and took down the information."
"Constant cold breezes through the front door necessitated my wearing my coat throughout dinner."
"Unfortunately the receptionist was extremely rude - was just trying to come here for a nice drink with my date - and I 'cut' in front of the receptionist at the door."
"Not a good place to eat if you want to hear the person you’re with!!"
"The music was turned up a little too loud for me on a Saturday at 11am but over all a fine dining experience."
"Not really much of a pub, plays Hispanic music and serves sushi."
Value
Pros:
"It was all incredibly affordable."
"The prices are very good for the heart of midtown."
"Prices were very reasonable."
"The food and drink was very good and not overly priced like a lot of places in New York."
"Prices were also very affordable."
"Prices are very fair when considering the location."
"Sean's serves great food at great prices, has a fun atmosphere, and the service was excellent!"
Cons:
"Just the standard adding of the (high) gratuity charge to the bill was a bit weird."
"Before you pay BEWARE of the TIPPING suggestions they put on their receipt."
"BE AWARE - certain wait staff add more to the tip after you sign the receipt and leave the bar."
"Sparkling water was probably brought from tap (so it should not be 4$, should be free or 1$)."
"Also check your receipts make sure they didn't already include a generous tip. :) you've been warned."
"I felt that what we ordered it was a bit high."
"However, like many places here, I dont like when someone decides how much the customer has to tip."