Old Stone House Restaurant Warwick NY Reviews Summary

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The place is beautiful & fabulously decorated, as well the ambiance on the outside is very nice."
• "Ambiance was so warm and cozy, we even walked around the whole place after finishing just to admire all the interior design details."
• "Every room is a different vibe from the tables to the wall designs and decorations."
• "You can't beat the beautiful setting in the wonderfully decorated interior and unique rooms, the comfortable and classy porch, or relaxing by the fire pit in the nicer weather."
• "The atmosphere is elegant in this exquisitely restored historic home."
• "The ambience gives a feeling of comfort and luxury."
• "Every corner of this gorgeous Inn instilled a great attention to detail that creates a warm and welcoming environment for the diners to enjoy."

Cons:

• "The restaurant is a beautiful, romantic ambiance but the service and quality was incredibly disappointing."
• "Our seating in the main dining room was loud & crowded."
• "We had to leave before dessert because it was too cold- they should have given us a free dessert for freezing us all night- but nothing."
• "It's the type of place 'one and done'."
• "Do not go there for new years eve. Totally overpriced for what you get."
• "We sat on the heated porch and it was cozy the whole time even with the rain and temps in the 30s."

Service

Pros:

• "Service was great- wonderful recommendations and attention to details! Brad was our server and is so fantastic and attentive!"
• "The service was excellent."
• "Service was top notch."
• "The entire staff was incredibly accommodating and our head server was personal and genuine."
• "Service was over the top great."
• "The staff was both attentive and friendly."
• "With a courteous staff consisting of individuals who are experts in their field."

Cons:

• "Our server didn't even inform us that there were specials."
• "The bus girl seem to be chomping on chewing gum during service, which is inappropriate."
• "The waitress did not come back and follow up if everything was all right until we had all been halfway through our meals."
• "The bartender was extremely disinterested in us."
• "Our waitress disappeared after we were served."
• "Waited for quite some time for our server to return."
• "The bus boy was rude and didn’t want to do his job."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Brunch is a 3 course prix fixe and the dishes are perfectly portioned."
• "Everything from the champagne we started with, the wine list, the turkey dinner with all the fixin's etc was excellent."
• "The steak tartar appetizer was particularly amazing."
• "Food was delicious and service was top notch."
• "Fantastic food from start to finish."
• "The filet mignon was delicious and cooked properly."
• "The food is creatively upscale, the drinks unique and the Tiramisu dessert is not to be missed."