Basta Pasta Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 37 W 17th St, New York, NY 10011, USA

Phone: +12123660888

Rating: 4.3
based on 159 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The black spaghetti with seafoods are flavor, just the right 'al dente' (chewy) level."
  • "Pasta cooked in the cheese wheel is something out of the ordinary and tastes pretty good too."
  • "Food was divine pasta cooked to perfection and cheesy to my hearts content."
  • "Pasta and fish dishes are excellently prepared and taste amazing."
  • "Their parmesan and prosciutto spaghetti was excellent, great mushroom dishes, and their tiramisu was also exceptional."
  • "The risotto was creamy but not heavy- the peas and asparagus and a hint of citrus help balance it out to make it a really enjoyable dish!"
  • "Every bite was so very tasty!"

Cons:

  • "For my taste, the actual pasta was lacking in something."
  • "The rissoto and pasta was a touched undercooked which was a little disappointing."
  • "The ONLY dish that we think is okay was the uni pasta."
  • "Both my girlfriend and I had pasta dishes that were just completely boring in flavor."
  • "The cheese wheel pasta was ok nothing to kiss the chef about not salty but if you add extra cheese that's where the salt comes in."
  • "Their spaghetti dish served at the table was watery and the pasta was under cooked."
  • "The only disappointment was the black spaghetti since it wasn't as creamy or flavourful."

Service

Pros:

  • "Good service but it can get crowded."
  • "The staff are super attentive and friendly!"
  • "The service was fine and I had no complaint."
  • "Pros: very friendly and professional staff from bus boy to hosts to wait staff."
  • "The service is top-notch."
  • "The service is perfect! The floor management... the waitress, everyone was super attentive."
  • "Overall servers were kind and professional."

Cons:

  • "We had an extra charge for the bottle of water, which we never ordered."
  • "The waiter get away with his disrespectful attitude because there is a mandated 18% service charge for 5 or more people."
  • "After reminding the waiter again, he made a face and brought it to our table."
  • "Staff is professional but cold and bored."
  • "Bad bad service."
  • "Service can be great but I felt a bit rushed by the waiter."
  • "Waiters aren't at all engaged."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The ambiance is lovely great and cheesy as well."
  • "Cool atmosphere, the kitchen is out and in the open, first thing you see when you enter."
  • "The dining area decoration was trendy, simple and pleasant."
  • "A true neighborhood atmosphere, something like from an old movie."
  • "The ambiance is more on the quiet side and great for chats with close friends and dinner dates!"
  • "The ambiance is lovely great for a date night."
  • "Ambiance is fantastic. 10/10!"

Cons:

  • "The place was so tightly arranged with tables and chairs. It was very uncomfortable."
  • "Very loud since it is an open kitchen."
  • "Their new decor turned out like some cafeteria."
  • "Not the best ambiance."
  • "It also didn’t have that Italian feel/coziness in terms of atmosphere/cultural decor."
  • "The interior is not what I’d consider luxe or particularly interesting and maybe a bit spartan."
  • "I’m not a fan of the chairs and how the tables are all close together, so I give the atmosphere a 3/10 - it’s not as private as I’d prefer but everyone is different. :)"

Value

Pros:

  • "This is a neighborhood pasta place that is very good with their pasta at a reasonable price (for NYC)."
  • "The house wine was really quite good!"
  • "Completely authentic, speedy, and amazing experience for the dollar."
  • "The price is very reasonable given the quality of the food."
  • "The food and wine is wonderfully priced for NYC."
  • "For what you get it's an amazing value."
  • "Everything is portioned pretty nicely (so you won't be stuck with way too much food)."

Cons:

  • "It is slightly overpriced but a nice way to woo your girl!"
  • "2 people with one app, 3 drinks, 2 entrees and one desert came out to 150 with tip which seems a bit overpriced for the meal itself."
  • "The bill can get pricey if you order a lot of smaller plates or wines, but the pasta themselves are not too bad."
  • "Place is pricey and we had two different pasta dishes."
  • "I paid $200 for the three of us for dinner, could’ve gone somewhere else with better ambience for that price."
  • "It’s expensive so I understand."
  • "Weak portions for the price."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.