Sadelle's New York Reviews Summary

Category: Breakfast restaurant New York

Address: 463 W Broadway, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: +12122543000

Rating: 4.3
based on 338 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The fish is fresh and amazing."
  • "The French toast was not your regular French toast. Heavenly."
  • "The house salmon was perfectly seasoned and the french toast was thick and flavorful."
  • "Our favorite was the French Toast and it’s one of the best we have ever had."
  • "Bagels, salmon, vegetables, omelets, and French toast were all delicious."
  • "The salmon plate is fresh and tasty with delicious bagels, cream cheese, the works."
  • "The food was fresh and delicious."

Cons:

  • "However, it was undeniably overpriced ($24 for a posh salmon cream cheese bagel)."
  • "The salmon is so thin you can’t taste it."
  • "Smoked salmon had no flavour."
  • "The food was not good, i had a barley and mushroom soup, yuk."
  • "The food was mediocre, service very slow and atmosphere wasn’t there."
  • "The French toast was raw on the inside."
  • "The oysters were tasteless and would not recommend."

Service

Pros:

  • "The service was terrific, the salmon and bagels (everything) were a delight."
  • "The staff was friendly and attentive."
  • "Our server was Enriquetta. She was awesome and gave us great recommendations!"
  • "The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating."
  • "Service was impeccable."
  • "Customer service was incredible and restaurant is cute."
  • "The staff makes you feel unbelievably welcome and comfortable."

Cons:

  • "We had a 1PM reservation for 4. Arrived on time, but weren't seated until 1:30PM."
  • "Aside from the impossible wait times, food was very average."
  • "First timers and tourists beware, the good food and amazing atmosphere averages to mediocre if you factor in terrible and rude service."
  • "The only little blip was the service - super friendly but sooo slow."
  • "Our server seemed to lack any awareness and basically did not check on us after we got our food."
  • "They were very busy so our waiter wasn’t super attentive."
  • "The service was very slow and seemed disorganized, we always had to try to get their attention."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Great food, beautiful venue, and a fun atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere is also very nice. It was a very pretty and charming place to be."
  • "Wow this place is defiantly worth all the hype."
  • "Wonderful atmosphere with thoughtful decor touches throughout."
  • "The atmosphere is beautiful. The Bellagio is a beauty, and you are now in the midst of its Conservatory."
  • "Very pleasant with a cool vibe."
  • "The place is lovely, high ceilings, relaxing decor and lighting - overall great place to brunch."

Cons:

  • "Lovely place for brunch but has a slightly pretentious atmosphere."
  • "The whole atmosphere is a bit over the top and only horrible people hang out there."
  • "The hygiene in this restaurant is questionable."
  • "It was very cold and crowded around with people waiting for their tables."
  • "The environment is nice but there’s so many little flying bugs all over the place bothering you, so weird."
  • "The hostess was rather cold towards us and made us feel pretty unwelcome."
  • "This is not a nice restaurant, despite what the prices and popularity indicate. The bathroom is dirty and we found a hair in our food at the very end."

Price

Pros:

  • "It's really worth checking out at least once."
  • "Definitely three dollar signs though (2 people ran about a $90 bill with only 1 drink total), but worth it for a special occasion."
  • "Brunch was delicious, and while on the pricey side, still reasonable when it comes to NYC."
  • "I attended a Brunch with about 4 people and the price was about $120 not bad at all."
  • "The prices reflect the service, food and atmosphere, so we believe they are justified."
  • "Although this was the most expensive breakfast I've ever bought, it was well worth it!"
  • "Expect to pay $$$ but this is Soho and well worth it if you're visiting."

Cons:

  • "For example a regular chicken sandwich shouldn’t be $28!"
  • "One tuna sandwich the size of a palm is $17."
  • "3 stars bc of a 20% service fee in 2022. The 20% service fee is ridiculous."
  • "The prices are insanely high - you get super thin salmon and some vegetables for 28$ with taxes."
  • "Prices are above average."
  • "Honestly the place is a 3.5, it’s not bad but quite overpriced."
  • "Food lacks however. Extremely overpriced."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.