"With a great UES location, perfect ambiance, massive always evolving menu, and really great service, this place is securely on my list of go to NYC spots."
"We love the combination of atmosphere, music, and food."
"First time coming here for a team outing. Loved the vibe and music."
"The restaurant is really nice and they have cute outdoor seating currently as well."
"Had a pretty awesome time here, the decor and the ambience was awesome."
"After 26 years of living in Yorkville, Conmigo feels like it is here to rescue me."
"The interior is so relaxing. That combined with the delicious food and drinks and great service gave me happy vacation vibes."
Cons:
"It was the worse meal I’ve ever had, and the service was lacking warmth and friendliness."
"Definitely not the type of place you will go if you are looking for a calm or quiet place."
"Food is great but dear lord do not sit inside. They were blasting music to an uncomfortable degree."
"Acoustics are bad (no curtains/rugs/etc) so the moderately loud music and conversation felt deafening- avoid if you have any kind of aversion to loud restaurants."
"The songs are very very loud to the point that it's deafening if you choose a place under one of the speakers."
"The music was a little loud so when it started getting busy it was hard to hear my friend speak."
"Our waiter... wasn’t pleasant at all.... he looked annoyed and aggravated."
Service
Pros:
"Service and food was amazing both times we went."
"Service was also really good."
"The staff are welcoming and the service is very good."
"The staff was so attentive and friendly!"
"Jack helped me out with my order. He made me feel very welcome and made great suggestions."
"Top notch service from our waiter Darwin."
"Service was friendly and quick. Food came right away."
Cons:
"It was the worse meal I’ve ever had, and the service was lacking warmth and friendliness."
"The service today was little slow and zoned out but maybe because of less staff or another busy day."
"Service was a tad slow, likely due to holiday weekend but it won't stop us from coming back."
"Con: extremely slow service. Our table was forgotten about multiple times."
"Our server in particular took a very long time to come by or in cases ignored our motions to come to the table, so our stay took longer than we anticipated."
"Terrible service, waited 40 minutes for them to bring my food."
"Our waiter... wasn’t pleasant at all.... he looked annoyed and aggravated."
Food & Drinks
Pros:
"The fish tacos were really tasty, but the fish was so unevenly distributed."
"Food is great."
"The cheese empanada with mint was actually really good!"
"Tommy's Margarita was authentic."
"Short rib tacos were flavorful and balanced."
"Margaritas are FRESH, no syrup mixes."
"Great happy hour, $29 for 1 hour unlimited margs/wine or beer and 3 tacos of your choice!"
Cons:
"It was the worse meal I’ve ever had, and the service was lacking warmth and friendliness."
"The guacamole is pre-made and way to chunky."
"The hot sauces were not spicy at all, the guac didn't taste fresh - like it was probably made a day or two before or had some sort of preservatives."