Tavern 5 Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant

Address: 710 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444, USA

Phone: +19738351426

Rating: 4.4
based on 204 reviews.

Atmosphere & Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere were really nice and clean."
  • "And the atmosphere was warm & comforting."
  • "Love the outdoor seating, inside is decorated nicely as well."
  • "Atmosphere and ambiance are truly comfy and cozy-rustic vibes overall."
  • "Ambiance was really nice - tons of outdoor seating."
  • "The atmosphere is what makes this place so attractive."
  • "The outdoor seating is very comfortable and has the mist spray to help keep you cool."

Cons:

  • "Nothing special....have been here more than once and both times it was so loud I could not hear people at my own table speaking."
  • "Huge hard blowing fan on the deck was a problem to speaking and eating."
  • "It's SO loud!!!"
  • "The band was WAY too loud, but overall the acoustics here are REALLY bad!!"
  • "When we were on the lawn another time, a tree's leaves were continually falling on us and our table."
  • "Picnic tables in area we sat were uncomfortable for some older guests."
  • "It was apparent that because we were outside we were often forgotten about."

Service

Pros:

  • "Fantastic Customer Service!! The waitress was awesome!! The Server Aaron was amazing."
  • "The service was OUTSTANDING!!"
  • "Never had a bad experience with food, drinks or staff."
  • "The service is exceptional."
  • "The staff still provides very attentive service."
  • "The service was GREAT all the staff were super friendly and nice."
  • "The service we received was excellent."

Cons:

  • "We requested to be seated by the patio where it was warmer, but hostess responded with, 'it’s meant for a bigger party.'"
  • "While the food was pretty good and I love the atmosphere, the service was horrible."
  • "We were told by the girls on the front that kitchen is closed 4pm-5pm, opens at 5pm and can't even sit outside on the back before 5pm, not even for a drink, only by the bar section."
  • "After dinner we wanted to sit outside and they said that they had dinner reservations beginning in 20 minutes."
  • "Furthermore our waitress had a personality of a stone and tried to get away from the table as quick as possible before we even finished our sentences."
  • "They just made us feel unwelcomed, outside was empty they could have accommodated us."
  • "Poor service. We hardly saw our waitress and it wasn't very busy."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was high quality."
  • "Everyone enjoyed their main course especially the seared shrimp and sea bass."
  • "The food is great."
  • "The truffle fries were outta this world!"
  • "Highly recommend the burgers, steak, and the bartenders make a fantastic old fashioned."
  • "The food quality is high."
  • "Food was amazing but service was exceptional."

Cons:

  • "The nachos were out of a can (specifically jalapeños and tomatoes), which is only annoying because the description really made it seem like they'd be great."
  • "We ordered burgers, they were good but no very flavorful."
  • "The tavern 5 burger was so spicy my husband and sister could not even eat it."
  • "For all 3 steaks to come out bad was disappointing."
  • "Food is no so good, drinks are not the best and their prices are too high for the quality of food."
  • "The food was VERY average."
  • "The food is good but over priced to me for what you get."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.