"The food was excellent and our server was very pleasant."
"Thanks Zuli (sorry if I got the name wrong) for the great service!!"
"Service was attentive and friendly."
"All other staff super friendly and helpful."
"She was kind, gentle, always ready to help and super attentive!"
"The servers were outstanding."
"Service was super friendly."
Cons:
"She also dropped a glass of wine and just seemed really frazzled and all over the place and took forever to come back like they didn’t have enough help."
"However, our experience was marred by poor service; we were ignored by the waitress, which detracted from our overall enjoyment of the dining experience."
"Docking one point because either the host or manager, not sure what position she holds, was extremely unfriendly."
"We arrived at the place, and after 45 minutes they told us that we had to leave because they had a reservation, but they never told us anything, the host was very rude and had a very bad attitude!!!"
"SERVICE 0/5: There was one server for all 16 tables that were outside."
"The wait staff was incredibly slow, rude, and unprofessional."
"The server constantly tried so hard to get us to leave asap, we felt super rushed and unwelcome."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The pizzas are incredible and the salads are also amazing!"
"Pasta is amazing, barata cheese with something lol I forgot, but it’s really good."
"The pepperoni pizza was delicious, and they have a homemade hot sauce to add to the pizza which added some extra flavor."
"The pizza was really really tasty. The ingredients tasted fresh and high quality."
"The pizzas are to die for."
"Really good pizza and decent pasta! I’d give them a 5/5 for the pizza for how fresh the ingredients are, the chewy yet thin crust, and sauce to bread ratio!"
"The Kale & Pecorino Salad is also just perfect - refreshing, light, and with a subtle complexity."
Cons:
"The carbonara was pretty bland as well."
"pizza was kinda burnt dessert was rlly good yummy olive oil cake with berries and the salad was decent."
"The marg pizza was barely edible w burnt corners."
"The pizzas were m way too much salty."
"The arugula/avocado salad didn’t have much flavor outside of the orange."
"The pancake we love so much came back uncooked in the middle."
"The pizza itself was a bit dry and the cheese didn’t feel like the most quality of quality."
Ambiance
Pros:
"The restaurant has a great vibe with a bunch of tables packed closely together (typical for West Village)."
"The ambiance was quite nice and decoration was sleek!"
"The restaurant is cute."
"It's cute and cozy with an open pizza kitchen and attentive service."
"It really felt like being in Italy for a while, as we sat in the sun in the afternoon."
"Cool rustic interior, plenty of tables and very spacious."
"Great new place in the village, took my kids there and felt like we were at home."
Cons:
"It just wasn’t fun to sit in the cold, poorly lit outdoor area."
"But what the manager did was the third and final straw."
"Racist employees. They did not seat us for 1 hour and 15 minutes and made us wait in 45 degrees."
"So so so noisy. Like, sore throat noisy."
"Space is a bit small, you’re eating side by side with other patrons even in outdoor seating."
"We were placed inside the heated shack adjoining the restaurant. They said that's considered inside I was disappointed."
"We were supposed to be seated just at the intersection of Perry and Greenwich in a very busy pedestrian and car area, but the nice hostess moved us to the back that would be great apart from the smell of garbage that the wind would blow in my face."
Value
Pros:
"I went for happy hour which are the hours between 4-6 pm. They have $4 beers, $5 spritz, and $6 pizza."
"They have amazing prices during happy hour like the most expensive thing is six dollars and we enjoyed the spritz which was also very good."
"The best happy hour in town! Pizza for $6 (extra couple of dollars for burrata), olives for $5 and cocktails for $5."
"Came here for happy hour, and it’s a steal. $6 Margherita pizzas? $5 spritz’s? Absolutely unheard of in NYC."
"Their happy hour is an absolute steal, a rare find in the city."
"This is a steal for happy hour drinks and food since wine and basic pizzas are $6, rosemary aperol spritz for $5, and beer for $4!!"
"Happy hour at rosemarys beer is $6 whereas happy hour at roeys beer is $4."
Cons:
"Good food, but needs to work on price point."
"I ordered a menu item that was listed as $15 but was charged $22 on the bill."
"In terms of price, it's even worse for the drinks."
"good for $30 during restaurant week but wouldn’t go again unless it was during happy hour probably."
"Watch out for their online menu - if you just click through without reading, it subscribes you to a $15/month recurring charge on your credit card."
"The manager was so rude to me, called me criminal because I asked if I could have the alcoholic drinks on a separate receipt."
"Worst experience in NYC, don’t recommend at all, it was a nightmare."