Coletta Reviews Summary

Category: Vegan restaurant New York

Address: 365 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10016, USA

Phone: +16468612889

Rating: 4.6
based on 265 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The wait staff was SO great."
  • "The staff is amazing and enthusiastic."
  • "The waitstaff was so kind and friendly, checking up on us to make sure we enjoyed ourselves."
  • "The staff was knowledgeable and just all around great."
  • "Service was great (and very fast!)."
  • "Service very attentive."
  • "The service is attentive, warm, & humble."

Cons:

  • "We along with others waited over an hour for our food before walking out and didn’t even eat."
  • "He did not show up after taking the order."
  • "All in all a solid dinner though towards the end service got much slower."
  • "Unfortunately the service wasn’t great and at one point we waited over 30 minutes between dishes."
  • "Service wasn’t great and we ended up waiting ~15 minutes for them to take our credit card."
  • "The service was friendly but very slow."
  • "Our server seemed to be totally not interested in even suggesting anything."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The steak tartare is amazing, and the chocolate budding dessert is the best dessert ever."
  • "Absolutely loved this place... Everything we ate was amazing."
  • "Every dish we tried was incredible."
  • "DELICIOUS meals."
  • "The Mozzarella-esque sticks were mouth watering good."
  • "The calamari was to die for in terms of texture and taste."
  • "The vegan tiramisu here is the best vegan dessert I have EVER had."

Cons:

  • "Not the best for takeout either as the prices are a little high for vegan food."
  • "The truffle pizza, which was a bit heavy."
  • "risotto - do not get. Just don’t."
  • "The truffle pasta was very weak in flavor and somewhat watery."
  • "I'd stay away from the chicken dish as it's very mediocre."
  • "Pizza was doughy with cheese that was runny."
  • "The flavor of the chicken is a little flat. It just didn't give me the zing I wanted."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The ambience was great, the food concept I liked and the waiters were very welcoming!"
  • "The spacious ambiance of their Midtown location is perfect for group outings."
  • "The restaurant has a warm and inviting atmosphere."
  • "The ambiance feels like an upscale Italian restaurant."
  • "The atmosphere was comforting and sophisticated."
  • "The ambience was very cool."
  • "The ambiance of the place was delightful."

Cons:

  • "Some areas you can be seated are a little dark."
  • "Only thing wasn’t ideal was how close the tables were to each other, but they probably added more tables since it was Valentine’s day."
  • "The ambiance is nice, if not a bit cold."
  • "Very dim lighting."
  • "The tables were extremely close together."
  • "I wish there was more lighting for better quality pictures."
  • "When we first arrive, we were seated in the front room with the bar and were the only occupied table which took away a bit from our first impression."

Value

Pros:

  • "Highly recommend this gem to all vegans xx"
  • "Pricing is absolutely spot on for the quality of food you get."
  • "Worth every penny."
  • "Restaurant a little pricey compared to others, but for the quality of food and service it is a great find."
  • "Considering the quality, the price is pretty reasonable (~$30/person is also enough)."
  • "Expensive but I'd say it was worth the price."
  • "It’s definitely worth it."

Cons:

  • "A little pricey but food doesn’t make you feel sluggish after eating."
  • "I would say the prices are a bit too much. The gnocchi was $18. I don’t think the quality/quantity was appropriate for the price."
  • "The prices are high here, so that's the reason we give 4/5."
  • "But it’s is pretty pricey."
  • "It's not cheap though; prepare to spend about 60$ per person."
  • "They charge a cake fee of $6 per person so my $80 cake just had $24 extra charges with 4 people."
  • "This is an expensive place and prices do not justify the dish."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.