Kinchley's Tavern Reviews Summary

Payment Method

Pros:

• "It’s cash only but they have an ATM in the building."
• "Bring cash or ATM card because cash is king at this local favorite."
• "Cash only though but ATM on premise."
• "It's cash only, though, so make sure you bring cash or prepare to get charged a fee at the ATM on premises."
• "Also, be sure to bring cash! They have an ATM and the withdrawal fee is reasonable, but be sure to bring cash if that sort of thing bugs you."
• "First off this place is strictly cash only. ATM on site just in case."
• "I'm 99% sure they only take cash and have an ATM at the entrance."

Cons:

• "They only accept 'cash,' which we all know why (tax purposes), yet, they charge tax. A little shady if you ask me."
• "Cash only a challenge considering today's financial technology."
• "Bring cash — they’re cash only!"
• "Big heads up, they are cash only."
• "Cash only is inconvenient for many."
• "Just heads up it's CASH ONLY and their ATM is set to max fees so bring cash."
• "Cash only, that’s annoying."

Service

Pros:

• "Service is friendly and the place has a warm feel to it while service is humming."
• "Our service was print and accurate."
• "The ladies behind the bar, really know how to do their thing. Extremely knowledgeable, efficient and friendly."
• "The staff was very friendly and sarcastic we had lots of laughs."
• "Staff is always attentive but really busy."
• "The staff is always very friendly and attentive."
• "Great service Trisha was awesome..."

Cons:

• "Today my server was rude & very inattentive."
• "Service is horrible."
• "The girl was very rude to him. We are paying customers, that aren’t happy. We shouldn’t have to deal with rude employees."
• "The woman in charge of the take-out is difficult and rude if you follow up with her about an order."
• "Service: slow, needs more workers to keep up with the demand!"
• "The server never followed up and put in our order for the pizza."
• "Our waitress left much to be desired."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Great atmosphere. I love places that have been around a long time and have some personality."
• "The whole interior brings you back in time."
• "You can't go wrong with this literal New Jersey staple!"
• "Old decor but somewhat charming."
• "A cozy atmosphere for the entire family!"
• "Fantastic ambience, cozy, food-noisy."
• "Great atmosphere, great times."

Cons:

• "I'm not a fan of dining inside because it's very small and always so packed."
• "The place is dark and outdated."
• "It was incredibly busy, it's quite a small dining room."
• "The room was very crowded, and noisy."
• "Still the same small crowded dining room."
• "Didn't feel wholly comfortable as this small place gets pretty packed, there's a wall that separates the bar and dining area, and the tables are very close together."
• "Terrible atmosphere. That place is straight out of the 70's."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Their calamari and garlic bread is also excellent."
• "Good food in an unpretentious atmosphere that attracts all kinds."
• "Super thin crust pizza and buffalo wings were delicious."
• "The pizza is one of a kind and delicious every time."
• "Best pizza on the entire east coast in my opinion."
• "They produce a delicious thin-crust bar pie at extremely reasonable prices."
• "Mozzarella sticks were awesome, crispy on the outside and gooey melted cheese."

Cons:

• "The cream of spinach pizza was too salty."
• "The sauce for mozzarella sticks was out of the jar (and not a good one)."
• "Half with meatball (which tasted like they were the frozen kind)."
• "The plain pie cook was perfect yet tasteless."
• "It was equally horrible – soggy crust, not tasty toppings."
• "Buffalo chicken pizza isn't that good though."
• "The pizza was not flavorful, it did not have a nice consistency, the tomato sauce was, in my opinion, just thrown on top of the pizza, the cheese did not taste well."