Catch NYC Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "It’s a very nice an elegant place with great quality food."
• "The food was SO GOOD!"
• "Food was superb! Prices are mid-range for NYC, but what you get is stunning."
• "The steak is very tender and definitely a premium cut."
• "The waygu melts in your mouth and the crispy shrimp was to die for."
• "Every piece of sushi I have had was absolutely amazing and crazy combo but the fried chicken sandwich was phenomenal."
• "The food is absolutely delicious and their drinks are spot on."

Cons:

• "Food is surprisingly mediocre here for the cost."
• "The chicken with potatoes was horrible. Potatoes wasn't cooked long enough. They were hard."
• "The Caesar salad was bland and they have a lemon Vinaigrette instead of Caesar dressing."
• "The brenzino was so bad and got sent back no flavor at all."
• "The food did not have any seasoning. We are not happy with our food."
• "The food was fine, good quality but quite overpriced."
• "No! Overpriced. Terrible food."

Service

Pros:

• "Our waiter was amazing."
• "The server Mike was funny and super friendly."
• "Our server was wonderful, she was quick and always checked in."
• "The waitress was great and kept us up to date with how much we had left running on the tab."
• "Our server was obviously very busy as his section was full but he checked in with us often."
• "The servers host staff and manager are all very friendly."
• "Service was one of the best I've ever had."

Cons:

• "No no no. The acoustic is terrible!!"
• "We had to change table and freeze outside as it was impossible to seat inside with the noise."
• "Drinks were not worth the price, tasted premade and one of our drinks was even hot."
• "First of all, the security at the front was awfully rude to us and giving us dirty looks."
• "Didn’t receive any interaction from management nor was anything comped off the bill for this horrible service."
• "Impersonable waiter; rushed us through and seemed unhappy we didn’t order appetizers—other waiters seemed cool though!"
• "Service was a little spotty."

Ambience

Pros:

• "Amazing ambience, good service but I felt the food was okay may be it's my poor choice of picking Prefix menu."
• "Atmosphere was hip and lively!"
• "The interior definitely brings you back to a sunny LA afternoon in a second."
• "What an awesome, multi-level restaurant! Nice ambiance and view of the surrounding area."
• "The ambiance was amazing. I was hoping we'd run into Beyonce and Jay-Z but no haps."
• "And a very good ambiance with great music and fun people watching."
• "The ambiance was lively and trendy."

Cons:

• "Music is good, but LOUD."
• "Can get a bit loud as the night progresses."
• "It is too small for the amount of people it needs to accommodate."
• "The noise level was insane! Not from music but from the crowded number of people in the room shouting over one another."
• "Ambiance is very lacking. We got seats at the second floor. It feels like a family diner spot and the chairs are so outdated."
• "It got too loud at one point because bar was too close to the dining area and there were many drunk people."
• "Music was too loud for a restaurant. The vibes were more like a bar and lounge."