Bill's Olde Tavern Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "Our server was a young man with long hair in a ponytail, I believe. Very attentive and pleasant."
• "The attentiveness of the staff was the best part of the mall for me."
• "Maria was our server and did an outstanding job."
• "The bartender was named Lauren, and she was the perfect server."
• "Our server Nick, was absolutely outstanding! He was knowledgeable about the menu and patient and accommodating to our large group."
• "Melissa made the experience even better."
• "I don't remember his name but our waiter was a Hispanic guy with glasses. He was excellent!"

Cons:

• "Just bad management all the way around."
• "Service at the bar was sluggish."
• "The waitress was so rude we almost left."
• "They seemed to be under staffed because there was very long periods of time in between interactions with the waitress."
• "The waitress, was very rude. She had an attitude with us the entire meal."
• "Our server didn't seem to care that we had a 1 year old with us."
• "Terrible, service was very rude as if she was annoyed that we were there."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Food was exceptional, especially the soups."
• "I had an amazing hamburger here. It was a 10oz burger cooked to perfection with amazing toppings."
• "The food ALWAYS comes hot and tasty."
• "The food is reasonably good and fairly priced."
• "Great bbq. Pulled pork is excellent."
• "The food has always been delicious each time I've been here."
• "The Crab Cakes are the best I have ever had."

Cons:

• "Pizza came to table burnt and sizzling Hot on a oven plate, that’s not how pizza should be served."
• "The wings were so overdone they had a hard black area that I couldn't even chew."
• "Brisket was dried out."
• "The greens seem like they came out of a package that was a few days old."
• "The meatloaf seemed to have been heated up in a microwave, hot in the middle cool on the outside."
• "The meat on the Reuben sandwich was all gristel and fat."
• "The chicken was hard like a rock and inedible."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Great atmosphere for an old tavern."
• "Came here for two friends reception and it was wonderful."
• "This bar is definitely a staple of my hometown."
• "This place very much has a local feel to it but was a very friendly and enjoyable place."
• "Old style interior. Great vibe inside, relaxed and friendly pub."
• "Nice chill place to hang out with locals."
• "It has an authentic historic Pub ambiance. Very cozy and welcoming."

Cons:

• "This building needs to be torn down. Not safe for anyone to be in there."
• "Very crowded and noisy."
• "Loud, really drunk, and obnoxious locals."
• "Tends to attract a younger crowd and definitely has a dive bar feel with drunk patron altercations."
• "Been there last week..outside open area was bad with stagnant water on the side..the bar area was dull."
• "Now it seems the menu is Asian and Spanish flare. Not the same as it used to be."
• "Is just a dive bar and doesn't even have an outdoor patio it's more like a smoking area outside that's very small."

Value

Pros:

• "A great rotation of specials, well priced drinks."
• "They also have 2 for $25 lunch specials which makes lunch affordable."
• "Prices seemed fair."
• "Good selection of craft beers."
• "I highly recommend this place if you want to go and have a good time. You won't regret it!"
• "The food is great! I had a chicken philly cheesesteak in a wrap, and there was soooo much chicken!"
• "An expansive menu with many items that you won't find at an average restaurant."

Cons:

• "Service was good but the bill was more than expected due to the prices charged were higher than the listed prices on the menu."
• "Stay away...unless you like this sort of thing! Two thumbs down!!!!"
• "Don’t spent money at this establishment."
• "Just don't go here. After the last visit... Let this place fail as it should have."
• "They are a bunch of scammers and robbers and will take your money because they are desperate."
• "I will NEVER waste the gas to come back here."
• "We left after one round because the vibe was just off."