"The food was very delicious and the customer service was phenomenal!"
"Excellent omelet and home fries!!!"
"The bacon was extra extra crisp."
"Food quality and portion sizing above average."
"The soup and bread were incredible."
Cons:
"Bread was soggy."
"Food was bland."
"They don't know what fried onions and mushrooms are supposed to be."
"The food was bad. I ordered a cheese stake with onions. It had more onions then stake."
"Food was just so-so. Had the prime rib special, potatoes were ice cold."
"The eggs tasted like eggbeaters not real egg, and the syrup for the pancakes was watery and had absolutely no flavor."
"The burgers were dry and cooked incorrectly."
Service
Pros:
"Best food, great prices, and awesome wait staff!!"
"Servers know your name, don't rush you out and always takes time to talk to you."
"Drinks were refilled without having to ask for them."
"Peter does a fantastic job in serving the customers and pays attention to details."
"Our waitress Sharon was very attentive and great to talk to both times we visited last week."
"Our waitress was fast, efficient, and friendly."
"The staff is doing a great job, keeping everyone safe with masks and the tables set up with distance between them."
Cons:
"Service felt rushed the seat were sticky, the food felt rushed."
"Waitress paid little attention to what came out, she obviously didn't care."
"Service was horrible."
"granted we were here on mothers day but our waitress was confused and sloppy."
"Server have the impression we were bothering her by being there."
"Food is always cold, not sure what the deal is with no sauce on the pasta or sandwiches either, even if you ask for extra sauce."
"And when I mentioned it to the staff the manager got huffy with me."
Atmosphere & Decor
Pros:
"They recently gave the place a face-lift and we really liked the updates!"
"Love a North Jersey diner!"
"Great staff, good food, big outdoor tent so you stay nice 'n' cool why you eat."
"It was so nice to have a meal out, under the tent at the Roxbury Diner."
"The remodeling has definitely modernized the interior."
"The place was renovated and looks great inside and out!"
"The atmosphere of the restaurant gave it an amazing experience it was like a mix of old fashion with new fashion but was blended in very well!"
Cons:
"The place is in need of a desperate renovation. Looks like they haven't touched the place in 70 years."
"The building is in need of an update and the parking lot desperately needs to be repaved."
"Going inside feels a bit depressing, the food is ok but unfortunately I don’t think it has a good variety to choose from."
"Nothing was really sanitized. Just normal wipe down with dirty water."
"The kitchen needs to be cleaner when you have a clean kitchen you have people eating there."
"Was served rotten meat (steaks)."
"After I got my check, I witnessed the chef at the carving station... pushing a slice of prime rib onto a plate with his DIRTY HAND, all without washing his hands in between, nor using a hand sanitizer... This is how germs like hepatitis are spread!"
Value
Pros:
"Great food at an unbeatable price."
"Make sure you come with an appetite because this is more than you could eat in one sitting food is fresh and delicious."
"The prices for the specials were decent, all around $10 or less."
"Less expensive than other diners nearby, while I still feel good quality."
"Good food at decent prices."
"Prices still affordable."
"Very reasonable."
Cons:
"The prices are high because of inflation!"
"The food is mostly microwaved and not worth the inflated prices."
"They did a whole renovation and passed the cost onto the customer."
"Take out orders are always wrong and if you call to let them know the response is 'what do you want me to do about it?'"
"Wasn't bad tasting but the prices were way too high."