"Food was hot, delicious, huge variety and the staff so kind and helpful."
"Sandwiches, pizza, dinner and appetizers are all delicious."
"The food fresh and tasty."
"Delicious fish dish over Pasta."
"The food was very tasty."
"The food was delicious, warmed to perfection and abundant."
Cons:
"The sauce tasted like water with thickener— no taste at all."
"I haven’t had an overcooked pizza in a while. Not great."
"Lots of grease on everything."
"So disappointed how the quality of food has declined in the last few years."
"The last several times we've ordered food it was far less than appetizing and upset our stomachs."
"Absolutely horrible food and even worse people running it."
"The whole dish was grey—un appetizing to look at."
Service
Pros:
"Fast service with 3 other families coming in at the same time 45 minutes before closing."
"The staff is great, the owners are friendly and call their customers by name, a true family restaurant."
"The service was excellent and the restaurant was spotless."
"Great family atmosphere! Staff is helpful, management outstanding, looking to please & make your visit enjoyable."
"The service was great, friendly and very warm."
"The service from staff is beyond exceptional."
"Always welcomed with a smile, and the service and food makes me smile."
Cons:
"Another older gentleman came up and asked what the problem was, when the gentleman who took my payment told him that the order was wrong he looked at me like I was the problem didn’t even apologize."
"The service leaves much to be desired."
"Called the manager tonight to see if he would be interested in a case study for Kean University. He rudely cut me off and said 'No!' and hung up."
"One of the busboys was constantly looking at his phone and not paying any attention to the customers."
"Service was very slow and when we arrived at 5:30 it was not crowded."
"Not sure what was going on but waiter was slow, pizza crust was hard."
"He was rude and not apologetic in any way."
Delivery & Catering
Pros:
"The amount of food they brought to my house I would’ve easily paid double for anywhere else."
"We highly recommend Dominicks for any size catering you need."
"We always order catering from Dominick's because the food is great, they are very timely, and the prices are very fair."
"I had a cheesesteak sandwich delivered to the Barn Hill Care Center and it was still so hot I had to wait to eat it."
"The staff is nice and they also deliver to our home which many other places don’t."
"My colleagues and I enjoyed lunch at Dominick's after volunteering at the Sussex County Food Bank."
"We had the best food and service provided by the staff at Dominick's."