P.J. Whelihan's Pub + Restaurant - Oaks Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The best part of the meal was the vanilla cookie with toffee & white choc chips served in an iron pan! Hot out of the oven & made fresh."
• "All of the food was FANTASTIC."
• "The food was incredible and everything came out just as we expected."
• "The food at P.J. Whelihan's is excellent, well-seasoned, and comes in a wide range of options."
• "The beyond burger was delicious made up as the Mushroom Swiss."
• "Food was excellent!"
• "The wings were nicely breaded and the hot honey sauce was full of flavor."

Cons:

• "The long wait we can understand but the quality of food is really disappointing."
• "Everything else was terrible and way over priced."
• "The soups were drenched in salt on top of salt with a little more salt!"
• "The burgers were worse than a fast food burger; rolls were cold not toasted and stale."
• "I ordered the French dip sandwich which was blood red (not cooked at all) and was dripping blood onto my plate."
• "The shrimp was overcooked."
• "The buffalo chicken sandwich had a drizzle of buffalo sauce that had soaked into the bread, it was certainly not 'tossed' in sauce."

Service

Pros:

• "Janet was a very tentative server and was pleasant as well."
• "Service was great and Chicken Buffalo Dip was good."
• "Our waitress couldn't have taken care of our table any better!"
• "Our server makenzie was the best part. She was very attentive to all of our needs, and she is so friendly."
• "Our server, Kiana was excellent. We were seated promptly and our orders were taken right away."
• "Our server Courtney was with us in a few seconds. She was amazing!"
• "Service was fast."

Cons:

• "Felt that the bartender was ignoring me until I was joined by two others in my party."
• "Came in on a Saturday afternoon for wings and beers. I sat at the bar and bartender was nowhere to be seen."
• "They gave us an issue splitting our check and made us do all the calculations ourselves as they 'didn't know who got what'."
• "Service is weak - mismanagement is probably the source of this problem."
• "Service very slow. Had to get someone to find my waiter after apps were long done."
• "We had to ask for flatware and straws. Not from our waitress of course because we couldn't find her."
• "Our server Jesse was slow and was sitting down at a table talking most of the time."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "This is not the local watering hole. This is a much nicer place."
• "Pj’s is one of my favorite spots to go to because of the great food, the environment, and the excellent service."
• "Nice place. Really pretty!"
• "Such a fun, energetic vibe."
• "The atmosphere was lively and inviting, with friendly staff making us feel welcome from the moment we walked in."
• "Yummy food, great Bartenders, amazing atmosphere, and great friends are what this place truly is all about!!!"
• "Atmosphere is fun."

Cons:

• "This was my favorite place to come to most days and lately no matter if I eat in or take out something is wrong with my food."
• "Too many other places nearby with just as great food and atmosphere."
• "He was young and clueless. No apology and clearly had no training to help him through the process."
• "The manager was sitting at the bar flirting with a waitress, too."
• "But for a date night, no. Not ever."
• "Way too many tvs and the same thing on every TV, makes no sense!"
• "There is not even an attempt to social distance, tables are back to back."