Martiny’s Reviews Summary

Category: Cocktail bar New York

Address: 121 E 17th St, New York, NY 10003, USA

Rating: 4.4
based on 102 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The service is great! The employees are very attentive to detail and always present if you need them or have any questions."
  • "Extremely attentive service."
  • "The service was great! Both waiters and bartenders checked on us from time to time."
  • "Outstanding service. It was inviting and professional without any pretentiousness."
  • "Each guest is warmly greeted by the host and accompanied to their seat."
  • "Staff was kind, efficient, and at the ready with recommendations."
  • "Service and presentation are impeccable."

Cons:

  • "I found the staff especially the server named Rio to be quite rude."
  • "He was very rude to me, I had never seen such a rude attitude towards clients before."
  • "Terrible customer service."
  • "Service too deserves note... the serves were noticeably agitated."
  • "We felt that the staff were very snooty and condescending towards our party."
  • "One or two servicemen didn’t live up to a Japanese standard when we went and seem quite pushy in making us order more."
  • "Most interactions felt forced and tense."

Cocktails

Pros:

  • "This is truly the best cocktail bar!"
  • "Both the signature menu and the seasonal menu were out of this world and easily some of the best cocktails I’ve ever had."
  • "Cocktails are delicious, with high quality ingredients and perfect execution."
  • "The bar tenders carefully crafted beautiful cocktails."
  • "The cocktails are unique with fun and interesting ingredients used."
  • "The cocktails were amazing, no disappointment."
  • "The cocktails here are phenomenal!"

Cons:

  • "The nice experience and special cocktails come with a price… ~$25-30 per drink."
  • "Drinks are on the pricy side."
  • "Maybe my palette just is not sophisticated enough but the drinks were all just okay."
  • "I didn’t find the martinis anything special and wouldn’t pay $26 for them, even in NYC."
  • "The drinks were all just okay and mostly 25-30 which is pricey even for NYC."
  • "The Guacamole Sour tasted like watered-down guacamole with some alcohol dumped into it."
  • "It was a garlic 'B&B Gibson' and it tasted like someone had marinated an armpit in bathwater."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Wow! What a gem and my new favourite spot in Manhattan!"
  • "The dim interior combined with the brick and wood aesthetics provide for an enjoyable, intimate atmosphere."
  • "The ambiance and space is beautiful."
  • "The atmosphere was really nice, almost a time travel back to the past."
  • "The place is very intimate and perfect for a date or catching up with others."
  • "Awesome Ambiente. Two stories. First floor is a cool bar. Second floor is more a living room style atmosphere. Perfect volume of the music - easy to have conversation. Stylish interior (exposed brick)."
  • "Really beautiful space and I enjoyed my drink, but the prices are way high, even for a high end bar in NYC."

Cons:

  • "Space is not too big inside."
  • "Many of the hot dishes were served cool/room temp."
  • "When we complained the next table was TOO LOUD... the manager said it’s the owner’s table and there’s nothing they can do about it."
  • "I found it difficult to enjoy because it felt like a downgrade from Angel's Share in every sense; less interesting/delicious drinks, less engaged service, less interesting atmosphere... But higher prices."
  • "All the fancy sounding ingredients - leather, porcini, mole - were either unbalanced or just barely there."
  • "The team ceremony was also just bizarre and neither me or my friend could stomach it."
  • "SKIP. There’re 100000 bars in the city you don’t want to waste your dollars or your emotional damage here."

Food

Pros:

  • "I also had some food and it was really good."
  • "The food is also what got me too. I already had dinner but I regret eating dinner bc I should’ve just waited and ate here instead."
  • "We were not wowed by the drinks. The food was fantastic."
  • "For food, we tried their Wagyu sando and Wagyu tartare, and I honestly cannot tell you which one was better, they're both delicious!"
  • "The best thing I consumed was the wagyu sando (it was also like $58 for 4 small pieces though…)"
  • "The food quality was decent, and well enough to harmonize with the cocktails you taste."
  • "Tasty bites (particularly the sweet corn tempura, karage and burrata)."

Cons:

  • "When the food finally arrived after almost 45 minutes of waiting, it was not at all appetizing."
  • "We waited over an hour for the food and when asking if it was going to come out he said 'sorry the kitchen is now closed and cant make your food' — which we order over an hour prior.."
  • "Many of the hot dishes were served cool/room temp."
  • "There were too many flavors going on it felt weird (it actually tasted like drinking a caprese salad??)"
  • "After 45 minutes, the waitress started hovering and offering the check."
  • "All the fancy sounding ingredients - leather, porcini, mole - were either unbalanced or just barely there."
  • "I ordered a cocktail and for the first time I didn’t like it, it was very sweet and it was hard for me to drink it."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.