Mayfair Diner Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food was great! Rosa was very polite and kind!"
• "The food there is fantastic if you're from Philly, you know, you're getting scrapple."
• "The Mayfair Diner has been around forever, it seems, and for good reason. This is the place for comfort food at reasonable prices and giant portions."
• "The food was amazing!"
• "Good food and good service. Ordered a Spanish omelette and they included a heated tomato broth or lite sauce with home fries cooked right and tender with crispy edges but plenty food."
• "The food was delicious; way above standard for a diner."
• "All of their food is great, but I highly recommend the hot roast beef and gravy sandwich or the hot turkey and gravy sandwich."

Cons:

• "The food was horrible, spent 2 days with a stomachache after eating just an egg omelette."
• "It's bad enough the food was not just overpriced it also was not very good."
• "The sandwich was soggy and sub par at best."
• "The ham was awful, and the sauce?... I'm pretty sure it was just pineapple juice poured from the can."
• "I am disgusted seeing multiple mice running around the floor of the restaurant."
• "spent almost $60 on a hair in a burger and overall terrible quality of food."
• "The only thing I rate bad is the bathroom because it is dirty and has graffiti."

Service

Pros:

• "The staff was friendly, the atmosphere was very clean and comfortable."
• "I enjoyed going to the Mayfair diner the waitress was very nice and she serve our table in a timely manner."
• "Our waitress Susie was AWESOME! So sweet and attentive!"
• "Waitress Cathy, was very helpful. Gerry, manager came over to make sure everything was okay and was willing to fix any issues."
• "The staff was exceptionally friendly."
• "The waitresses are friendly and polite."
• "Everyone here is so pleasant all the time! The coffee is great and the waitresses are all SO friendly and sweet😊"

Cons:

• "The waitress who served me was very rude. She has a nasty attitude the whole time."
• "took 15 to 20 minutes for a waitress to take my order."
• "Every time I went (about six times) my order was either wrong, took forever, not brought out at the same time, not cooked right."
• "The waitress was ignorant every time that I asked a question."
• "Went there for lunch today.. waitress was good ..that's about it.. our food was cold and the orders were wrong.."
• "Waitress had me sit there for more than 10 mins, completely forgot about my existence."
• "The service at the front here is terrible."

Price

Pros:

• "This is the place for comfort food at reasonable prices and giant portions."
• "Great food at affordable prices."
• "The food is always good and reasonably priced."
• "Their food is great and decently priced."
• "Good food. Good prices. Good portions. Staff very friendly. And quick."
• "Good service, decent food with good prices. The diner may look small on the outside but it's actually fairly comfortable inside."
• "Not only is the food delicious, but the atmosphere is clean, warm, and inviting."

Cons:

• "Almost 2 weeks ago... Two breakfast came over 35 dollars."
• "8.99 for 1 waffle 8.99 for 3 pancakes Wake up!!! Way too high Won't be back."
• "French toast with bacon alone went from 6.99 (price displayed online) to 14$."
• "spent almost $60 on a hair in a burger and overall terrible quality of food."
• "The Mayfair dinner was once a inexpensive, breakfast choice, my girlfriend and I both worked in the food industry so we were but taken a back at the $70 total."
• "Went to pick up my food and was charged 65. Was told their online prices are outdated."
• "$11 for breakfast that I couldn't even finish never again."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "The atmosphere was absolutely superb."
• "Everything was perfect."
• "The diner was clean and the staff very nice and friendly."
• "The 50’s setting, the friendly staff, the DELICIOUS food: it was all perfect!"
• "It was completely renovated. The Atmosphere in there was so amazing."
• "The diner is accessible, with wide isles, plenty of open tables and roomy booths."
• "This is the place to go for great food and friendly service. My family used to go here when I was a kid and I go here a couple times a week for breakfast."

Cons:

• "It was cold in the restaurant the entire time."
• "The only thing I didn't like was the other waitresses talking about other people at the counter right across from my table."
• "The French toast soggy and the home fries cold."
• "Decor is in need of updating, but it is an old cart style diner."
• "Parking is tight."
• "Lady at front counter a little intense regarding masks."
• "Table and seats were dirty. Crumbs and scrambled egg pieces on seat and table."