Mays Landing Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner

Address: 6177 Harding Hwy, Mays Landing, NJ 08330, USA

Phone: +16096255051

Rating: 4.3
based on 154 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The meals were fantastic."
  • "Our favorite this far are the breakfast skillets 3 out of three meals ordered were all the rave."
  • "I ordered the senior meat loaf dinner as a first test of their food, and it was amazing."
  • "The food was simply Delicious! Large portions, I had three meals from my order!"
  • "Everything is delicious, amazing, and comes out fresh and perfect!"
  • "Food tasted more high quality compared to other diners."
  • "Everything was DELICIOUS!! Soup was stuffed pepper soup soooo good!!"

Cons:

  • "The food was horrible, it was over done."
  • "Meatloaf was old, dry and close to inedible."
  • "What a terrible meal. I ordered stuffed flounder with crab. The crab was full of shells and the flounder over cooked."
  • "The fruit was hard and inedible."
  • "The soup taste like celery and dirt."
  • "The chicken pot pie, it was inedible. Smelled and tasted funny."
  • "Food was horrible. And it was breakfast."

Service

Pros:

  • "Staff was friendly and helpful, treated you like family or friends."
  • "Service was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu items."
  • "Service was great."
  • "Service was excellent and so was the country omelette."
  • "Customer service was awesome too! Very friendly, helpful & FAST."
  • "Our waiter, Louise, was exceptional!"
  • "Service is top notch from the hostess who in my opinion is the backbone of the diner to the amazing and professional servers."

Cons:

  • "Service adequate, no iced tea refills offered."
  • "It was tough getting a refill on drinks, and our waitress left the wrong check on our table."
  • "We had to wait to be seated, then we sat for 15 minutes at least and not a single person came over to say they would be a few minutes."
  • "Food is usually good but they are so short on servers that it takes awhile for food to come out and by the time it does the food is cold."
  • "I’ve never had such poor customer service and unacceptable food that prompted me to write a review."
  • "She took incredibly long to bring us our drinks or anything really!"
  • "After being seated our waitress gave us water and then forgot about us."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "An awesome place to eat. Because of COVID-19, they were only serving outside under a tent, but hey, that's a sign of the times right now."
  • "The place is spacious, clean and inviting."
  • "Atmosphere was comfortable with plenty of seating."
  • "Always inviting and comfortable."
  • "The environment reflects a past when eating out was a special moment in your heart."
  • "If a homey diner is what you’re looking for, this is definitely the spot for you."
  • "Diner is clean and well kept."

Cons:

  • "Not the same diner as it used to be. Back in the day this was the place to eat."
  • "Dining area was not clean... especially to be late night when there were approximately 5 parties in the entire diner."
  • "Noticed lack of maintenance. Half of lanterns on outside of building weren't lit."
  • "Went tonight for dinner and diner was freezing. Almost everyone had their jackets on."
  • "We did have one issue: the ceiling began to leak right over my mother's plate."
  • "So service wasn’t good when u walked in, the owners was very rude."
  • "I felt the host that was going to seat us was very rude."

Price

Pros:

  • "Prices were reasonable."
  • "The price was good too as it was cheaper then eating at a chain for 3 people."
  • "The prices were inexpensive and the food was tasty."
  • "Had the giant Mays Landing Seafood Supreme Combo. It was HUGE, fairly inexpensive."
  • "Your meals come with soup, salad, dessert and drink for under $20 so it's worth a visit."
  • "The specials include your meal, soup, salad, drink and dessert for under $25."
  • "Food is better than most other diners and more reasonably priced."

Cons:

  • "This bare bones sandwich was 12.95, which in my opinion, is just way way too expensive for such a basic sandwich."
  • "Wish I didn't have the pay the upcharge of $3.45, but it made it better."
  • "Their prices are outrageous for being diner food!"
  • "Overall, not my favorite diner. It’s very hit or miss and their sandwiches (which are my typical orders) are extremely overpriced."
  • "Prices are high compared to other establishments especially for the size of it!"
  • "Sad that a diner feels they need to charge another $1.50 on top of an already overpriced platter for a tiny additional portion of bread."
  • "Bland, rubbery chicken for 17.99."

Menu Variety

Pros:

  • "Typical diner setting, very large menu!"
  • "They have various omelettes, filling skillets, and just an overall big selection in menu."
  • "Their menu is huge with a wide variety of foods from breakfast to Greek, Mexican and Italian."
  • "They had a lot of Greek cuisine on their menu too which I probably would have tried if I weren't off meat."
  • "The breakfast menu is vast with so many delish options that it can take a while to decide."
  • "The menu selection has such diversity, you'll read it over and over just trying to decide."
  • "Their menu is vast, and I mean vast, tons of options for everyone and all tastes."

Cons:

  • "The salad had old broccoli and chunks of lettuce core in it."
  • "The omelette was lacking shrimp for a seafood omelette."
  • "Got the soup /salad and come to find out, sorry all out. Forgot to take it off the board."
  • "No Vegan menu."
  • "The 'greek salad' it rested on was not an authentic greek salad."
  • "It tasted freezer burnt almost seemed like the breading was a fish fry breading."
  • "The avocado toast was a piece of dry toast and a very small slice of avocado that looked bad!"

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.