New Monmouth Diner Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food was so delicious! They offer a lot of choices at reasonable prices and the portions are really good."
• "Any time of day the tropical pancakes are amazing."
• "The food is exceptional with very large, I mean very large portions."
• "Both of the meals we ate were delicious and cooked well."
• "Stopped there for lunch while driving through Jersey. I ordered an eggs Benedict with crabcake on an English muffin, it was amazing."
• "Had classic cheeseburger and miami burger and both were excellent and juisy with crunchy fries."
• "The food was great."

Cons:

• "The food is hit or miss lately and the service has gone downhill."
• "Every food item was bland and had NO TASTE."
• "Food was horrible. I brought it home for my dog."
• "The steak dinner turned out to be hamburger meat covered in some disgusting sauce with bland mashed potatoes and cold broccoli."
• "The food wasn’t anything special and the wait was way too long for mediocre food."
• "The side potatoes were completely tasteless."
• "The fish was sous vide and not broiled."

Service

Pros:

• "GREAT service - Merri was our server and she made our meal very pleasant."
• "Service was quick."
• "The service is always great."
• "Waitress was friendly."
• "The service was excellent."
• "Wait staff was attentive and food came out quick!"
• "Service was sincere and speedy."

Cons:

• "Called the restaurant for over an hour to get this resolved and they sent me to voicemail all 45 calls."
• "Hostess was rude walking in the door."
• "No one waited on us or even greeted us for a good 10 minutes."
• "Owners and servers laughed as people rose and left or ran out."
• "Waited 10 minutes for someone to even come over and take our drink order."
• "The waitress we had was horrible and the manager had to get us drinks because she took so long."
• "Service: .5. Unfriendly waitress and inattentive."

Ambience & Cleanliness

Pros:

• "It's a nice cozy Diner."
• "Great environment, amazing staff, and superb food."
• "Fairly conveniently located diner along Route 35."
• "The ambience is very funky and fun."
• "Place was clean."
• "The atmosphere is amazing."
• "Both the exterior and interior are very nice...make you want to stop."

Cons:

• "Bathrooms were filthy, to say the least, and under stocked on toiletries."
• "Was it the sticky floor in our booth? The dirty windows? The unkempt men's room? The flies?"
• "I sat in a booth with dirty hand prints and things running down the wall."
• "The caddy that held the condiments was full of crumbs and clearly not cleaned in a very long time."
• "Surprisingly the front entrance was littered with cigarettes butts and paper."
• "Place was hot inside and there were flies everywhere."
• "The floor was filthy."