Tim McLoone's Supper Club Reviews Summary

Category: Bar & grill

Address: 1200 Ocean Ave N, Asbury Park, NJ 07712, USA

Phone: +17327741155

Rating: 4.4
based on 118 reviews.

Staff and Service

Pros:

  • "All the staff were amazing to work with, they were right there when needed and quick to respond with any questions we had."
  • "Working with Samantha and Victoria was simply flawless."
  • "Victoria was the greatest wedding planner and made sure the stress was off our shoulders."
  • "The staff was very friendly and accommodating."
  • "The staff and maître D, were very accommodating to me my staff and the guest."
  • "I appreciated the kindness of the waiters and waitresses and how they tended to my dietary restrictions."
  • "Our waitress was attentive yet not intrusive."

Cons:

  • "The service was the horrible."
  • "Unfortunately the table service was nonexistent. Water glasses remained empty the duration of our meal."
  • "After ordering our food never saw the waiter again."
  • "Neither of our coordinators were able to be found... hours before the event ended, and we were apparently left in the hands of the maître d."
  • "We attended an event and the waitress assigned to our table was lousy."
  • "Very bad service.come here a lot and tonight there where empty tables and the Manager told me that the kitchen was backed up on a Saturday night under staffed."
  • "Horrible service for a wedding."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food was absolutely delicious, and the event managers were friendly and responded to my every need throughout the whole planning process."
  • "The food was spectacular and everyone raved about how great it all was."
  • "Our food was delicious and plentiful."
  • "The food was awesome (my Italian best friend said it was the best penne vodka she’d ever had - and it was!)"
  • "Food was delicious. Especially the crab cakes, ravioli stuffed with spinach, pizza w/fresh mozzarella and basil."
  • "Our guests were blown away with how delicious everything was."
  • "Wow, we went there for a wedding, and hands down, the best food and appetizers we ever had."

Cons:

  • "Genuinely disappointed. The kitchen got really messed and the table next to us ended up having to leave because their food took too long."
  • "The Lobster bisque soup was inedible."
  • "Food was a but pricey for me."
  • "The mashed potatoes were way too salty, barely any sauce."
  • "The food quality was just a step above diner food. Unfortunately, it didn't taste fresh."
  • "All of the party members who asked for filet got well done. It was like chewing on leather."
  • "The chicken francese was a little dry and the sauce was nothing special."

Venue and Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "It was perfect. Yes it is a beautiful location and venue, but I think the real magic of this place is the staff and the food."
  • "Incredible place and right on the boardwalk overlooking the water was stunning."
  • "It’s an amazing venue... you won’t be disappointed."
  • "It is a beautiful venue in a wonderful location right on the Asbury Park beach with great food."
  • "The views of the ocean, the layout of the room and all the windows made this venue just the perfect spot for us."
  • "The venue is stunning, located right on the beach, offering a breathtaking backdrop."
  • "The private event space here is beautiful with perfect ocean view and lots of natural light coming in from the big windows."

Cons:

  • "A great place to see good musicians/concerts but the food is very expensive and not good at all."
  • "Several pieces of décor were not placed in their designated location listed in the plan and other items like the wedding programs were not even placed out at all."
  • "The only downside to this venue is that the parking last Sunday was an absolute nightmare since they don't have a private parking lot or valet parking here."
  • "The room had a damp/swampy air about it, the booth seating was laughably lumpy-uncomfortable."
  • "They decided to hang our donuts on some donut wall they had, instead of the stand that we provided."
  • "This place sucks never ever come back or recommend."
  • "The room is AMAZING and absolutely STUNNING at night."

Price and Value

Pros:

  • "Upscale food at reasonable prices."
  • "The dinner packages they offer are a good deal."
  • "Lunch with drinks was not cheap, but in these difficult times, definitely worth the price."
  • "Great/quick service, delicious food (probably the best calamari I've ever had)."
  • "Food and service was very good."
  • "Nice setting, attentive and energetic service, clean bathrooms, very good entertainment."
  • "Nice ocean views from the room and the outside deck (in warmer weather!)."

Cons:

  • "We spent money per person for a table of 6 for British Invasion. The band was excellent everything else is terrible."
  • "Entertainment is good food is a little pricey, and you have to by tickets, but must spend a minimum of $20. PER PERSON to watch the show you paid to see."
  • "It was really good this time... Although sometimes they're terrible."
  • "It was absolutely so much fun and the food was delicious but a little pricey."
  • "Cold toast on BLT and charged an extra $6 for some added turkey breast... Atmosphere is great…prices too high."
  • "Overall not the best for lunch when it cost over $220.00 for a lunch."
  • "Mixed drink prices were a little high especially considering it was a private event with an open bar for beer and wine."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.