Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings Reviews Summary

Atmosphere & Decor

Pros:

• "Great atmosphere and food."
• "Everything about this place is great. Staff friendly and helpful. Nice atmosphere. Reasonable. Very clean."
• "Nice local and lively place."
• "You are immediately greeted and felt comfortable by the decor."
• "Clean & Cool vibes, good music environment made it perfect."
• "I really liked the interior design of this place."
• "The interior is clean and modern with the city feeling."

Cons:

• "The place is not maintained."
• "The entire place is DIRTY."
• "The floors are slippery and dirty."
• "We will never go back there! And I will be sure to tell all my friends and family how dirty this place is!"
• "Place was empty on a Sat afternoon … why?"
• "The location is much smaller than their other locations and feels more cramped."

Service

Pros:

• "The bartender was great."
• "Our bartender Serina was very attentive made a Great Manhattan."
• "The service is excellent. Especially the waitress Selena."
• "The staff at the Marlboro NJ location was great."
• "Lillian was our server and she was terrific."
• "The staff are so friendly and efficient."
• "Britany (the bartender); exceptional service-personable and knowledgeable."

Cons:

• "Most of all my server was a young man with no manners."
• "Women Manager has no customer service manner at all."
• "Horrible service waited over an hour in an uncrowded restaurant."
• "We just sat there for about 20min and nobody came over."
• "Awful customer service takes over 35+ minutes to get just two sandwiches with a completely empty restaurant."
• "Waited at the take out area for quite some time before I was acknowledged."
• "One of waitresses simply ignored my ask to try to change the channel on one of the TVs."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Their traditional pizza is full of flavor."
• "The pizza, the chicken wings, delicious."
• "They make decent margarita pizza."
• "I highly recommend the tuna lunch sandwich if you are not sure what to get."
• "The meatballs and eggplant parmesan were fantastic."
• "Their garlic Chicken wings were really good and the sauce was not overly salty."
• "The pizza. My wife immediately said this is awesome."

Cons:

• "The sauce and the cheese were awful. Sause was too zesty and the cheese was way too salty."
• "Their tagline, 'Well-Done,' fits because our pizza was burnt."
• "Don't bother with the wings, they are too dry and burnt to enjoy."
• "My wings came out burnt."
• "The sauce has no flavor or taste."
• "The garlic knots were extremely chewy on the inside dough and the eggplant pizza’s dough was uncooked and soft and cold."
• "The pizza ordered was too dry."